Comments on: Creamsicle Ice Cream Recipe https://suebeehomemaker.com/creamsicle-ice-cream-recipe/ Family-friendly savory and sweet recipes! Thu, 19 Mar 2026 21:28:56 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.0 By: Suebee Homemaker https://suebeehomemaker.com/creamsicle-ice-cream-recipe/#comment-52083 https://suebeehomemaker361.e.wpstage.net/?p=60501#comment-52083 In reply to Celine Gittins.

Thanks Celine!

]]> By: Celine Gittins https://suebeehomemaker.com/creamsicle-ice-cream-recipe/#comment-51430 https://suebeehomemaker361.e.wpstage.net/?p=60501#comment-51430

One of the best creamsicle recipes I’ve tried and had, love it!

]]> By: Suebee Homemaker https://suebeehomemaker.com/creamsicle-ice-cream-recipe/#comment-47193 https://suebeehomemaker361.e.wpstage.net/?p=60501#comment-47193 In reply to Rebecca.

Were all of your ingredients super cold before adding to the attachment? If not, it’s difficult to get the ice cream to freeze.

]]> By: Rebecca https://suebeehomemaker.com/creamsicle-ice-cream-recipe/#comment-47182 https://suebeehomemaker361.e.wpstage.net/?p=60501#comment-47182

The flavor of the base is delicious, but after churning in my KitchenAid ice cream attachments, it was like soup. Put it in the freezer and still soup. What did I do wrong??

]]> By: Suebee Homemaker https://suebeehomemaker.com/creamsicle-ice-cream-recipe/#comment-33893 https://suebeehomemaker361.e.wpstage.net/?p=60501#comment-33893 In reply to Meredith.

I’ve never used honey in ice cream so I can’t say for sure!

]]> By: Meredith https://suebeehomemaker.com/creamsicle-ice-cream-recipe/#comment-33872 https://suebeehomemaker361.e.wpstage.net/?p=60501#comment-33872 Can I sub honey 1:1 w the white sugar?

]]> By: Suebee Homemaker https://suebeehomemaker.com/creamsicle-ice-cream-recipe/#comment-20949 https://suebeehomemaker361.e.wpstage.net/?p=60501#comment-20949 In reply to Mary Evans.

Hi Mary. I haven’t tested this without regular sugar so I really can’t say for sure.

]]> By: Mary Evans https://suebeehomemaker.com/creamsicle-ice-cream-recipe/#comment-20923 https://suebeehomemaker361.e.wpstage.net/?p=60501#comment-20923 Can you make this sugar free?

]]> By: Suebee Homemaker https://suebeehomemaker.com/creamsicle-ice-cream-recipe/#comment-20071 https://suebeehomemaker361.e.wpstage.net/?p=60501#comment-20071 In reply to J.

So happy to hear this, J!

]]> By: J https://suebeehomemaker.com/creamsicle-ice-cream-recipe/#comment-19975 https://suebeehomemaker361.e.wpstage.net/?p=60501#comment-19975

I love it!! I’ve tried a few of your ice cream recipes and they’ve all been fantastic! Thank you!

]]> By: Suebee Homemaker https://suebeehomemaker.com/creamsicle-ice-cream-recipe/#comment-19435 https://suebeehomemaker361.e.wpstage.net/?p=60501#comment-19435 In reply to Boomer.

I think I’d try using a teaspoon or two of the orange extract. It’s easier to be generous with vanilla extract since it’s a classic ingredient. But since I’ve not tried orange extract, I’d add a little bit less. Good luck!

]]> By: Boomer https://suebeehomemaker.com/creamsicle-ice-cream-recipe/#comment-19425 https://suebeehomemaker361.e.wpstage.net/?p=60501#comment-19425

Rating this one high even though I haven’t tried it, but the Mint and Chocolate Chip and Mexican Chocolate came out perfect, so I assume this one will too! Quick question: if using orange extract, how much to use? My first guess is to swap out one of the tablespoons of vanilla extract for orange extract, but figured it couldn’t hurt to ask!

]]>